Peter C Gøtzsche and Anders Sørensen in their article titled “Systematic violations of patients’ rights and safety: Forced medication of a cohort of 30 patients” alleged violation of patient rights by psychiatrists with the use of force, thereby causing immense harm. In this commentary I try to understand their motivation, expose their bias, make an evidence based counterpoint, explore real life consequences of their views and make a case for nuanced discussion on complexities in mental health.