Peter Gøtzsche’s proposal to provide anonymity to certain people reporting bad practices within the pharmaceutical industry, regulatory apparatus or health systems is superficially appealing but likely to generate more problems in the longer run than it might solve in the short term. We need to analyse what features of our systems generate problems and correct those, rather than rely on insiders to report on the resulting problems, as all these reports do is offer a false sense of security that things are safer now that one problem has been identified.